Toast was the star of Season 4 weekly update The Secret Life of Toast. Toast was abandoned by Matt on the bus and embarked on a whirlwind musical career, only to descend into drugs and abuse that alienated longtime girlfriend and Action 9 News reporter Natasha Stone (Tally). Toast appeared in The Season 4 Finale and was a contestant in RapStar 64K, but was eaten by fellow inanimate LRR contributor Gibb. The original Toast was eaten by a mouse while in the second Moonbase and was discarded. The crew's adoration for Toast baffled Kathleen.